Military Justice in Ukraine: Why Human Rights Defenders Warn Against Recreating Military Courts
The discussion on restoring the military justice system continues amidst the war, but the Pryncyp human rights center warns of risks to the rights of service members.
👥SocietyPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- Ukraine is actively debating the restoration of its military justice system.
- Human rights advocates warn against command pressure on military judges.
- The civilian judiciary can handle military cases through specialized judicial training.
- Creating separate military courts poses significant structural and independence risks.
The issue of developing a military justice system has returned to the spotlight due to the work of a Temporary Special Commission of the Verkhovna Rada. The full-scale war has heightened the importance of legal protection for service members, prompting parliament to seek optimal models for reviewing military-related cases. Meanwhile, experts express serious concerns regarding the potential revival of specialized military courts and prosecutor's offices.
Risks of Command Vertical Influence on the Judiciary
Proponents of restoring military courts often argue that judges need specific military experience and knowledge. However, human rights defenders emphasize that if the Ministry of Defence or the General Staff assign military ranks to judges, it creates a direct threat to judicial independence. Under such conditions, military judges would be bound by disciplinary statutes and the principle of single-command authority, inevitably increasing the risk of pressure from commanding officers.
- Civil society and experts warn against judge dependency on military leadership.
- Concerns exist regarding potential restrictions on subordinates' rights without a proper balance of commanders' accountability.
- Service experience across various branches does not automatically guarantee objective and impartial rulings.
“For a service member whose case is being reviewed, all of this means the risk that the decision will be influenced by the command vertical rather than the law and the circumstances of the case,” the human rights center notes.
Over the years of the full-scale war, the existing civilian court system has accumulated significant experience in handling such disputes. Instead of creating a separate vertical of military courts, experts suggest implementing a narrow specialization for civilian judges with the involvement of relevant experts, preserving impartiality standards and ensuring effective protection of military personnel's rights.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
Ukrainian national dead, two others rescued in Romanian mountains
Romanian rescuers and border guards located three Ukrainian citizens lost in the Maramureș mountains, resulting in one fatality and two survivors.
🛡️SecurityPoland demands NATO strengthen eastern flank air defense after Russian missile breach
The Polish Ministry of Defense insists on bolstering air defense capabilities following a Russian missile intrusion, while opting against triggering Article 4.
Rescuers recover body of third victim from rubble of residential building in Dymer
Emergency crews in Dymer, Kyiv region, have recovered a third body from beneath the wreckage of a five-story building hit in a recent strike.
Slovak Minister Makes Controversial Claims Linking Ukrainians to 1968 Prague Spring Crackdown
Slovakia's Foreign Minister Juraj Blanár claimed that Ukrainians were behind the 1968 Soviet invasion, sparking sharp domestic backlash.
💼EconomyPoland Reports Russian Disinformation Amid Incidents in Kaliningrad Region
Poland records a wave of Russian fake news regarding a purported Ukrainian attack on the Kaliningrad region involving NATO allies.
🇺🇦UkraineRussian Strikes on Energy Infrastructure: Naftogaz Facilities and Gas Stations Targeted in Dnipropetrovsk and Zaporizhzhia Regions
Russian forces launched an aerial bomb strike on a gas facility in the Dnipropetrovsk region and attacked gas stations in Zaporizhzhia, injuring a worker.